Ideology profile · Radical left

Communalism

Communalism, as developed by Murray Bookchin, proposes that political life should be rebuilt around face-to-face assemblies in towns and neighbourhoods. These municipalities would federate with one another, hold the economy in common and organise it on ecological lines.

Most pronouncedFederal 95%Democracy 95%Collective 85%
STRUCTUREPOWERLIBERTYWORLDFORCEBELONGINGOWNERSHIPMARKETSTRADEFAITHVALUESFUTURE
Core positions
  1. The municipal assembly of citizens is the basic unit of democracy.
  2. Municipalities should confederate rather than submit to a nation-state.
  3. The economy should be municipalised and run with ecological limits in mind.
Twelve axesRank of 46
Structure
Federal
Unitary
95% · Very strong#4
Power
Democracy
Autocracy
95% · Very strong#1
Liberty
Freedom
Security
75% · Strong#8
World
Global
National
70% · Leaning#10
Force
Pacifist
Militarist
70% · Leaning#5
Belonging
Pluralist
Assimilationist
80% · Strong#3
Ownership
Collective
Private
85% · Strong#6
Markets
Planned
Free market
70% · Leaning#11
Trade
Open
Protectionist
60% · Leaning#16
Faith
Secular
Religious
85% · Strong#6
Values
Progressive
Traditional
85% · Strong#2
Future
Techno
Bio-conservative
60% · Leaning#8
Origins

Bookchin set out the programme, which he also called libertarian municipalism, from the 1970s onward in works such as The Ecology of Freedom (1982), drawing on the Athenian assembly and New England town meetings. Abdullah Öcalan adapted it as "democratic confederalism", which has shaped the self-administration of the Kurdish-led regions of northern Syria since 2012.

Main criticisms

Skeptics doubt that assemblies can manage the scale and technical complexity of modern economies, and worry about the pressure on individuals to conform in small communities. Other anarchists object that it still relies on majority rule.

Neighbouring ideologies
93%

Libertarian Socialism

Radical left
92%

Anarcho-Communism

Radical left
88%

Syndicalism

Radical left
Furthest ideologyFascism38%
Where it fits best

Countries and historical regimes whose 12-axis profile is closer to Communalism than to any other ideology in the test.

How close are you to Communalism? Take the 60-statement test. Your result ranks all 46 ideologies by how closely they match your answers.Take the test →

Method: each ideology is placed at a typical position on the 12 axes, scored from 0 to 100 toward the first pole. Ranks compare it with the other 45 ideologies; matches are 100 minus the average distance across all axes. The positions are our own calibration, not taken from any third-party source.